KopTalk.com Forums Football Liverpool FC Forum Who needs to come in & to in the summer?

no i was never looking for some sort of "fact based argument"stats can be bent to suit a discussion." beaten most men"for example.that may not state he was running down a blind alley and got tackled by the 2nd player who he was never going to beat.the fact that as an attacker he has less assists than our 2 full backs is no great argument.and how does a player who has a better shot accuracy and conversion rate get the same amount as goals as the player with less?but this isn't about whether Salah is better than Mane.Mane is a much more rounded player than Salah.i would much rather have 2 Mane's than 2 Salah's but its only my opinion.Salah is very one dimensional and predictable.again only my opinion.he may have a better scoring rate than Suarez did for us,but does that mean he's a better player than Suarez was for us?not in a million years.
All im saying is that at the moment Salah has a value that is much higher than his actual ability.so if a big offer came in i would take it and hope that Klopp could use the money to improve the team.

50m 100m 150m 5 pound. Does not matter what we sell him for it is who Salah would be replaced with.

Salah is a hugely important part in a well oil machine. You're nearly better talking about what players we could sign if we sold him. He is a top level player as in all the big teams would want him if he is leaving tomorrow. There is a small list of such players.

Without his goal vs Napoli we would not have moved past the group stage, his goal against Southampton when he ran half of the field also kept our title challenge. That's just 2 contributions off my top of head. 44 goals in debut season, back to back golden boot winner, a huge star and role model in Egypt and the entire Arab world.

Can you tell me who we can buy that can contribute like Salah?

How does being a role model in Egypt and the whole Arab world count as a contribution to the team?i couldnt care less how he is viewed in Egypt it doesnt make him a better player.
im sure in Egypt they think he's the best player ever because he scored the goal that qualified them for the world cup.it still doesnt change the fact that he's one of the most one footed players ive ever seen and cant take a corner to save his life.these are basics for a pro footballer.he is no better than Sane at Man city and he cant get into the city side.inface i would say that Sane is a better player than Salah and if he played on the other side i would be more than happy to sign him as a replacement.

How does being a role model in Egypt and the whole Arab world count as a contribution to the team?i couldnt care less how he is viewed in Egypt it doesnt make him a better player.
im sure in Egypt they think he's the best player ever because he scored the goal that qualified them for the world cup.it still doesnt change the fact that he's one of the most one footed players ive ever seen and cant take a corner to save his life.these are basics for a pro footballer.he is no better than Sane at Man city and he cant get into the city side.infact i would say that Sane is a better player than Salah and if he played on the other side i would be more than happy to sign him as a replacement.

How does being a role model in Egypt and the whole Arab world count as a contribution to the team?i couldnt care less how he is viewed in Egypt it doesnt make him a better player.
im sure in Egypt they think he's the best player ever because he scored the goal that qualified them for the world cup.it still doesnt change the fact that he's one of the most one footed players ive ever seen and cant take a corner to save his life.these are basics for a pro footballer.he is no better than Sane at Man city and he cant get into the city side.infact i would say that Sane is a better player than Salah and if he played on the other side i would be more than happy to sign him as a replacement.

It means there is a huge market out there that the club can use eg shirt sales. I remember years ago we wanted an Asian player to target that demographic to generate more funds for the club. As for Sane being better well that's your opinion.