He was better than carragher against Bolton thats for sure , mind you that wouldnt be difficult cos he has been pants this year so far !! As for saying he was a flop in Scotland ??? Err living in Scotland i get to watch most of the games , and he was actually one of Rangers best players that season , scored important goals as well and then got a good move to Germany , who didnt want him to go either ,and was good for AEK last season , so all in all he wis a good signing for the money paid IMO anyway