Wow Ged...more sense from you here than I'd ever think of hearing from you. Although I think you have been a little harsh on Carra!! has ecrtainly been a fantastic defender in his time at the club but I believ his past two season have been slightly better than average!
Listen it hurts me to be so harsh on Carragher becaus he's a great lad and fantastic proffesional. My biggest gripe about Carragher is that throughout his Liverpool Career he has been used wrong, he should of been used as a versatile player rather than in one position which i dont think he is good enough to nail down. If you look throughout recent history of all the best teams they all had a versatile player which won them the league Liverpool has Stevie Nicol who provided cover for Hansen, Lawrenson, Craig Johnston as well as Jim Beglin, Everton had a player called Alan Harper who covered Gary Steven's, Peter Reid, Paul Bracewell and Kevin Sheedy and finaly United had Phil Neville who covered Gary Neville, Paul Scholes and Roy Keane. There is no way these teams would of been successful if it were'nt for these types of players and they are just as important as the ones who play everyweek if not more important, every tean during the season has injuries, suspensions and losses of form and thats when these types of players come into there own. We are lucky to have one in Carragher who could of played both full back positions, centre half and at a push holding midfielder, we just never used it to our advantage, this would of freed up other positions, as I say I would never sell Carragher but the feller is limited in footballing ability and should not be making nearly 600 appearances for the club given his limited footballing ability.
