KopTalk.com Forums Football Liverpool FC Forum Salah or Mane?

Who would you most want to keep?

Mane for me.

FSG out!

We reach an awful lot of fans worldwide because of Salah and he seems like he brings a great personality to our dressing room, unlike Mane who at times looks like a wet weekend in Blackpool.

They both add strong attributes to the team and it would be a travesty if either of them were sold, considering what Klopp is currently building. I don't think there could be any excuses from FSG to appease if either of them are sold. Cases could be made for the previous sales of Coutinho, Suarez and Torres because in the grand scheme of things we didn't have the dosh at them times to strengthen to where we wanted to be. Now we've been told the money is there and we are starting to win silverware again...if either of them wants to go to Spain or Italy we should dig our heels in because we are now superior than any team in either of them Countries. Tell them to give us 3 more years, when they're 30 and we'll look again at the situation.

Tough one but my intuition says Mane because I think we have better cover for Salah in Shaq and probably Harvey Eliott in a couple of years and Salah has a higher value.

I would prefer we keep both, but I would let Salah go as I think we have more cover for him, Mane from the left is more difficult to replace for what he gives the team.

I think it might come down to which is the biggest bid we get, which I expect would be Salah as he has a much bigger Global profile/brand than Mane.

TBH I don't like how we are "normalizing" the fact we are going to lose another "star" player! We currently have no need to cash in, we have been told that our finances are rosy and that we have money to strengthen without the need to sell before we buy.

After next season their prices will start to depreciate fast, so I can see us selling, a bit like Arsenal used to do when they were reimbursing their loan. We have Anfield to further develop

Mane. Mane has been our best player in the last 2 years, and has been consistent since he joined us. I love Salah, but you can't take away what Mane gives us. I also think Salah is more likely to leave.

We have often sold our best players when they are just going past their peak, players like Keegan, Souness & Torres, but I think they have another 2 years in them at least, I hope they are both with us next season, also depends what Klopp has planned, he want to change it around abit to bring in Mbappe!

Mane!no question

Why do I have to choose one - they're both reds.

It's like asking - if you had to lose a testicle, which one would you pick?