KopTalk.com Forums Football Liverpool FC Forum Klopp Has Spoken - Its Official

Lucas isn't a regular so why mention him? Gini, despite what you say, is a very good player but for me should be played further forward.

So would you have been happy had we signed any of those players before the weekend?

Im not saying them players like sigurdson are the answer or they are good enough for us but they are better than some of the players currently there. If you want to push Wijnaldum on forward, who do you take out?

With 11 in 33 shots on target would you really risk putting him further up the pitch? Ive outlined his weaknesses with things to back it up as to why i think hes not good enough for Liverpool starting 11.

It's almost like you want to sign someone just to get a chance to see a new player in our team. And when the novelty wears off you will want us to sign another new player, and another and it will go on and on.

Personally I hope we don't sign anyone this month, unless there was a top player that became availible. I would enjoy seeing people moan on here and people having a go at FSG.

So why not compare him to Lalanna, Coutinho, Can etc? And he's also a different kind of player to Lucas so how is it a fair comparison?

I think Gini got something like 15 or 16 goals for a relegated Newcastle last season from midfield.But he's playing a deeper role this season which is why he's not doing so well. I think the feeling was he could do that deeper role and still score but it hasn't worked out as yet. That's not to say he isn't good enough especially when he's having to adapt to a different role.

They'd still moan RS. We could buy Messi and Ronaldo and they'd moan we didn't get Neymar too.

No he wouldn't.

Sigurdsson is an attacking midfielder, so to get in our team he would need to replace Mane, Lallana, Coutinho or Firmino. Is he better than any of them? Not for me.

He plays in the CM role and ye he goes forward but hes not a no10 like lallana/couthino or mane. As for not signing anyone RS. I know you dont want us to sign anyone. Just because the chances of us not getting top 4 would be increased then you could turn around and say stupid [oops] like "is klopp any better than rodgers?". It doesnt matter what I or anyone says to someone like you because in your mind signings like Balotelli and Mignolet are a massive success.

As for the FSG thing. They said "we can compete". Did they or did they not? 1 LC trophy and thats it under them. 1 champions league qualifing year. Thats why people have a go at them. That record is hardly competing now is it?

He's not a central midfielder, Swansea's central midfield against us was Carroll, Fer and Cork. Sigurdsson plays further forward because he is an attacking midfielder.

You don't know me very well because I don't agree with any of that.

Your saying you would be happy if we didnt sign anyone knowing the chances of us not getting top 4 would be increased? Ill flip the coin for all the wishful thinkers as well, your saying you would be happy if we didnt sign anyone that would decrease our chances of possibly winning the league? I put it in both cases for you.

Are you really that f*king deluded you think people just come on to have a go at FSG with no basis or foundation?

1 LC trophy, 1 champions league qualified for. Justify that?

Did they or did they not say we could compete with bigger teams? Can we? NO.

You can sit there and let this club fall like forest and other clubs like leeds and Villa. I think it would give you a good excuse to starting watchin the spl.