It's not just that trep, it is the 10 years as much as anything. Basically the way I see it, he hasn't done the job in 10 years, and the last time he did, he failed. That doesn't sound like the most qualified candidate to me.
i didn't say he was the right choice, just that you can't judge him on the newcastle time - there was so much trouble there he was on a hiding to nothing
i am not convinced he is the right choice, he was great first time round while Sir Bob Paisley was there to give him advice, but after Sir Bob left him to it we ended up with players like Speedie ...... maybe his time away from the game will have given him a new outlook on the game and time to refresh his ideas and learn from watching in the wings ....... no way of knowing but i would hate him to lose his iconic status by failing 2nd time round ..... Dalglish seems to be the most likely option though