KopTalk.com Forums Football Liverpool FC Forum The offical transfer and manager rumour thread.

id take doyle before mcgeady. mcgeady is way to inconsistent.

Is McGeady any more inconsistent than Babel tho? I think he could do a job for us hes had a poor season but I think if he came and hit form early on he could be a success, one of those crowd favourites like yossi.

No offence Emp but you recommending a player is like the Yorshire ripper going door to door selling avon cosmetics to lonely housewives.

Is Rafa the man to give players a kick up the arse though. If he can't get Stevie and Nando playing, what chance will he have with McGeady? I think if the price is right it wouldn't be the biggest gamble in the world to take him.

It's unlikely we'd get Mcgeady anyhoo i dnt think celtic would sell but its a good call i certainly wouldnt complain if we failed on young n went for him instead.

arda would cost between £12-15m. i really think we should get him or mata.

simao is a good player but he's turning 31 this year. it would be crazy to pay £8m for him.

Mata is a good shout, dont think he would have any problem with the physical side of the premier league either, it just boils down to the price tag valencia put on him, they have to sell so they will want clubs bidding of each other, maybe Rafas spanish conections would pull the right strings, you never know

both mata and silva will leave. i can't see them staying now that villa has been sold. silva is madrid bound so we should get in for mata now before someone else will get him.

I agree the sooner the better, id love to see them both here along with Ever Banega (aslong as he stops gettin naked on webcams)I rate all three very highly but £15m if thats true and thats all we have then i think we will struggle. May have to look elswhere.

Sorry guys but "LFC" and "acting quickly in a transfer window" don't go hand in hand.