KopTalk

Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
Rate Thread
Page 5 of 8 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Joined: Apr 2013
Posts: 3,908
Under 23 Player
Under 23 Player
Joined: Apr 2013
Posts: 3,908
Explain the committee then.

Joined: Mar 2013
Posts: 1,270
S
Under 23 Player
Under 23 Player
S Offline
Joined: Mar 2013
Posts: 1,270
Originally Posted By: imadk
Explain the committee then.


What committee? our setup is no different to any other club. The committee is just an excuse to blame the owners for our terrible transfers.

FSG set a budget.
Rodgers tells his scouts what kind of players he wants.
The scouts headed by Fallows search for players that match Rodgers request.
Rodgers, Pascoe, Ayre, Edwards and Fallows sit down and discuss which players would benefit the club.
Rodgers gives the green light on which players to sign.
Ayre negotiates with clubs.
Edwards reports back to FSG.

Job done, it's nothing more than that.

Joined: Jun 2009
Posts: 22,394
Liverpool Legend
Liverpool Legend
Joined: Jun 2009
Posts: 22,394
Originally Posted By: Spice Boys
Originally Posted By: imadk
Our defense (or lack of it) would have been much different if Clarke were still here.


Clarke won't work with Rodgers though, especially in the role he would have been given. Rodgers didn't want him, he wanted Pascoe as his number 2.

I think Kenny had worked out a new boot room, in that he would manage for 2-3 years and then Clarke would take over with Keen as his number 2.

Clarke is a football manager in his own right.


Rodgers wanted Clarke to stay on but he wanted to go out of respect for Kenny and to try his hand at being a manager.

Joined: Dec 2009
Posts: 2,886
Under 23 Player
Under 23 Player
Joined: Dec 2009
Posts: 2,886
Originally Posted By: Stanley Park
It does not happen often I agree with marko it would be crazy to sack rodgers now only to replace by a half measure that we regret again in 12 months time. The club needs to take a long hard look at the structure the personnel and the processes because our problems go far beyond the manager. And marko only pointed out rumors that were occurring in Serbia nothing wrong in that especially when they turned out to be true. This does not mean in think nothing is wrong but we can't afford to keep messing up like this



Another in agreement Stan, however much I wish I wasn't- just meaning the transfers look a shambles and we have no one queuing up of any class to turn this train wreck around.


Happy days.


Government is not reason; it is not eloquent; it is force. Like fire, it is a dangerous servant and a fearful master.

George Washington
Joined: Apr 2010
Posts: 4,229
D
Under 23 Player
Under 23 Player
D Offline
Joined: Apr 2010
Posts: 4,229
Originally Posted By: imadk
Explain the committee then.


Don't know if this has been posted before but it does shed a little light and, if it's all true it explains a lot. This is an interview with Echo reporter James Pearce, I took it from this is anfield.

James Pearce has given an insight into the club behind the scenes
https://soundcloud.c...earce-corrected

The transfer committee is composed of
Rodgers
Ian Ayre
Mike Gordon (FSG representative)
Dave Fellows (Head of recruitment)
Michael Edwards (number cruncher)

Rodgers insists he has the final word on transfer, however Rodgers has been having to pick from 2 or 3 man short list which did not include players he initially wanted (due to fee, availability etc)

Rodgers really wanted:
Lovern
Lallana
Lambert
Vorm (cost too much, club were not prepared to pay)
Bertrand
Boney
Eriksen

Transfer committee wanted
Can
Markovic
Moreno
Balotelli (Rodgers didnt want 2 weeks before he was signed, as other deals fell through and was left with a choice of Eto or Balotelli)


FSG wanted a director of football, but Rodgers opposed this. However FSG in essence got a DOF by committee.

Muddies waters who is held to account. FSG still fully behind Rodgers, and still has credit in the bank despite poor start. But FSG expect a top 4 finish.

Rodgers wanted another keeper in the summer to push Mignolet (Vorm). Mignolet not sweeper keeper Rodgers talked about when he arrived.
Rodgers has said to Pearce its tactical why Borini has not played (not performed in training). Reading between the lines he believes Rodgers was frustrated at Borini for rejecting the moves, and generally he has not impressed. The club are making it abundently clear they want him gone.
Rodgers left out new signing as he felt he needed to go back to what he knew. Thats why seen Lucas and Toure return to team, and players like Can left out.

Joined: Jun 2009
Posts: 22,394
Liverpool Legend
Liverpool Legend
Joined: Jun 2009
Posts: 22,394
Originally Posted By: derek
Originally Posted By: imadk
Explain the committee then.


Don't know if this has been posted before but it does shed a little light and, if it's all true it explains a lot. This is an interview with Echo reporter James Pearce, I took it from this is anfield.

James Pearce has given an insight into the club behind the scenes
https://soundcloud.c...earce-corrected

The transfer committee is composed of
Rodgers
Ian Ayre
Mike Gordon (FSG representative)
Dave Fellows (Head of recruitment)
Michael Edwards (number cruncher)

Rodgers insists he has the final word on transfer, however Rodgers has been having to pick from 2 or 3 man short list which did not include players he initially wanted (due to fee, availability etc)

Rodgers really wanted:
Lovern
Lallana
Lambert
Vorm (cost too much, club were not prepared to pay)
Bertrand
Boney
Eriksen

Transfer committee wanted
Can
Markovic
Moreno
Balotelli (Rodgers didnt want 2 weeks before he was signed, as other deals fell through and was left with a choice of Eto or Balotelli)


FSG wanted a director of football, but Rodgers opposed this. However FSG in essence got a DOF by committee.

Muddies waters who is held to account. FSG still fully behind Rodgers, and still has credit in the bank despite poor start. But FSG expect a top 4 finish.

Rodgers wanted another keeper in the summer to push Mignolet (Vorm). Mignolet not sweeper keeper Rodgers talked about when he arrived.
Rodgers has said to Pearce its tactical why Borini has not played (not performed in training). Reading between the lines he believes Rodgers was frustrated at Borini for rejecting the moves, and generally he has not impressed. The club are making it abundently clear they want him gone.
Rodgers left out new signing as he felt he needed to go back to what he knew. Thats why seen Lucas and Toure return to team, and players like Can left out.


Interesting if true. It basically means Rodgers has the final say on who we buy but they might not be who he wants or thinks he needs.

Joined: Mar 2011
Posts: 8,595
H
1st Team Squad
1st Team Squad
H Offline
Joined: Mar 2011
Posts: 8,595
Originally Posted By: fazakerley red 1
who the fu-k is no mark Dave Fallows ???

And where the fu-k did he come from? And what the fu-k does he know? And why the fu-k is he here? And fu-k him and the horse he rode in on!!!

Joined: Apr 2010
Posts: 4,229
D
Under 23 Player
Under 23 Player
D Offline
Joined: Apr 2010
Posts: 4,229
Originally Posted By: wilkij1975
Originally Posted By: derek
Originally Posted By: imadk
Explain the committee then.


Don't know if this has been posted before but it does shed a little light and, if it's all true it explains a lot. This is an interview with Echo reporter James Pearce, I took it from this is anfield.

James Pearce has given an insight into the club behind the scenes
https://soundcloud.c...earce-corrected

The transfer committee is composed of
Rodgers
Ian Ayre
Mike Gordon (FSG representative)
Dave Fellows (Head of recruitment)
Michael Edwards (number cruncher)

Rodgers insists he has the final word on transfer, however Rodgers has been having to pick from 2 or 3 man short list which did not include players he initially wanted (due to fee, availability etc)

Rodgers really wanted:
Lovern
Lallana
Lambert
Vorm (cost too much, club were not prepared to pay)
Bertrand
Boney
Eriksen

Transfer committee wanted
Can
Markovic
Moreno
Balotelli (Rodgers didnt want 2 weeks before he was signed, as other deals fell through and was left with a choice of Eto or Balotelli)


FSG wanted a director of football, but Rodgers opposed this. However FSG in essence got a DOF by committee.

Muddies waters who is held to account. FSG still fully behind Rodgers, and still has credit in the bank despite poor start. But FSG expect a top 4 finish.

Rodgers wanted another keeper in the summer to push Mignolet (Vorm). Mignolet not sweeper keeper Rodgers talked about when he arrived.
Rodgers has said to Pearce its tactical why Borini has not played (not performed in training). Reading between the lines he believes Rodgers was frustrated at Borini for rejecting the moves, and generally he has not impressed. The club are making it abundently clear they want him gone.
Rodgers left out new signing as he felt he needed to go back to what he knew. Thats why seen Lucas and Toure return to team, and players like Can left out.


Interesting if true. It basically means Rodgers has the final say on who we buy but they might not be who he wants or thinks he needs.


Important too that he did have players forced on him.Still doesn't justify not playing Can or Borini when there's an obvious need.
Also if it's all true, Rodgers is going nowhere.

Joined: Jun 2009
Posts: 22,394
Liverpool Legend
Liverpool Legend
Joined: Jun 2009
Posts: 22,394
Whether he thinks Borini is good enough or not, at least he's a striker and what can he lose by trying him? Can too. Going by that Rodgers didn't want him but now he's here and looked decent enough, why not give him a go?

The situation isn't ideal as all managers want to bring in who they want and that's the way it should be. But Rodgers should be man enough to try all at his disposal.

Joined: Dec 2009
Posts: 2,886
Under 23 Player
Under 23 Player
Joined: Dec 2009
Posts: 2,886
Originally Posted By: wilkij1975
Originally Posted By: derek
Originally Posted By: imadk
Explain the committee then.


Don't know if this has been posted before but it does shed a little light and, if it's all true it explains a lot. This is an interview with Echo reporter James Pearce, I took it from this is anfield.

James Pearce has given an insight into the club behind the scenes
https://soundcloud.c...earce-corrected

The transfer committee is composed of
Rodgers
Ian Ayre
Mike Gordon (FSG representative)
Dave Fellows (Head of recruitment)
Michael Edwards (number cruncher)

Rodgers insists he has the final word on transfer, however Rodgers has been having to pick from 2 or 3 man short list which did not include players he initially wanted (due to fee, availability etc)

Rodgers really wanted:
Lovern
Lallana
Lambert
Vorm (cost too much, club were not prepared to pay)
Bertrand
Boney
Eriksen

Transfer committee wanted
Can
Markovic
Moreno
Balotelli (Rodgers didnt want 2 weeks before he was signed, as other deals fell through and was left with a choice of Eto or Balotelli)


FSG wanted a director of football, but Rodgers opposed this. However FSG in essence got a DOF by committee.

Muddies waters who is held to account. FSG still fully behind Rodgers, and still has credit in the bank despite poor start. But FSG expect a top 4 finish.

Rodgers wanted another keeper in the summer to push Mignolet (Vorm). Mignolet not sweeper keeper Rodgers talked about when he arrived.
Rodgers has said to Pearce its tactical why Borini has not played (not performed in training). Reading between the lines he believes Rodgers was frustrated at Borini for rejecting the moves, and generally he has not impressed. The club are making it abundently clear they want him gone.
Rodgers left out new signing as he felt he needed to go back to what he knew. Thats why seen Lucas and Toure return to team, and players like Can left out.


Interesting if true. It basically means Rodgers has the final say on who we buy but they might not be who he wants or thinks he needs.


Which is what I've been saying forever.

This is a combined disaster and they either need to admit that the procedures that lead to this have to go NOW and Rogers has to pick his own players, or they don't really trust him and all are cleared out and replaced with a new traditional format and a manager with no interference.

Can't see how this can go any other way from here if we are to improve in future.


Government is not reason; it is not eloquent; it is force. Like fire, it is a dangerous servant and a fearful master.

George Washington
Page 5 of 8 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

Moderated by  KopTalk Team 

Link Copied to Clipboard
ShoutChat
Comment Guidelines: Do post respectful and insightful comments. Don't flame, hate, spam.
Advertisements
Liverpool FC Discussion