we do know tho. he was clearly angry over the dempsey thing and he(clint) went for the fee that was expected anyway. If it was a wage thing BR would have been first to say so. And FSG came out and said it was due to them thinking he was an expensive midtable player.
Please link me FSG's statement, as currently you seem to be reworking events to suit yourself. BR pulled the plug on the Siggy deal as he would only match the agreed deal that swansea had agreed. The Dempsey deal was left in the hands of IA.
He left melwood fully expecting a deal would have been agreed, hence his anger of being left with a thin squad.
He likely only agreed to Carroll's loan on the basis of bringing in another.
Why the deal broke down is as far as I'm concerned is unknown and in-house.
The hating on FSG is unwarranted. So far I can't complain as their only real mistake is backing a fan appointed manager. So if there is someone to blame it is you, and you and, you, and them, and that lot over there.
January might not be as helpful as we all hope, so I believe next summer is the true reflection on how the owners run the club.
Another consideration is that Joe Allen's position would likely be the same as when Dempsey would fit. Maybe the truth is that liverpool didn't want to pay money for someone to warm the bench.