KopTalk.com Forums Football Liverpool FC Forum "WHATS THE TIPPING POINT" ????????

hypothetical question then FSG give the fans a choice , your choice is give brendan a big chance with the ups and downs that will happen for a bit , or the appoint benitez and we have the same ups and downs ?

rodgers of course. raffa had his chance.

well thats my call but i dont know if the % would be in favour in the liverpool f.c. world .

i would never take raffa back. or any manager for that manager. KD was a one off and an appointment under exceptional circumstances. hopefully br does the job. if we fall further its maureen time.

Nope i say give Brendan a chance for sure im 100% behind him i may say 1 or 2 negative things true out the season but he'll still have my full backing he obviously impressed FSG with his CV and all the stuff about the playing style and the long term plan FSG are business men their here to make money which is fair enough but they'll want someone who they think will be a success and get us back in to the top 4.

Still think Henderson will come good, not world beater but may be as James Milner. Think he has the potential but not confident enough to play at a club where expectations are high. Doesn't have enough bottle yet.

Adam would be an ok squad player but if we get a good price (above 5m) should go. Jay S should go for free if needed. He is more of a liabilty.

Borini,still probably early days but not impressed so far and can't see him being our goal poacher that I thought we recruited, as this is where that the most important improvement was required. IMHO Caroll makes a bigger impact than him.

I would take Benitez.He has won more,and kept us in the top 4 for most of his tenure,kept getting us to the latter stages of the champions league.I was happy with that.
Rodgers,left Reading in the bottom 3 of the championship,he left watford 2nd bottom in the championship,got Swansea promoted and done well in his first season.
I would choose Biesla over both of these though.

we had good times with rafa but need to mention here that then 4th was almost gauranteed even with [oops] performances...

I agree competition is harder now Man city,Spurs and newcastle all overtaking us.But just worried we are trying to stabilise in this 6-8th position instead of busting a gut to get back into fourth onwards.My opinion is Benitez has more nous about challenging at the top,but Rodgers may surprise me.

As said before Benitez had his chance, did his maximum. Then did not do well and got the sack at Inter. Not having a top job for 2 years says a lot. Now BR has his chance, Came to us without big credibility but convinced our businessmen owners. Let' wait and see. Doesn't mean that we should keep quite if we are not happy with his decisions even if we are proven wrong afterwards.