Ok, please read the post before you try to tell me how wrong I am. I didn't say what he would play, but I what I would like to see. Totally hypothetical and based on my preferences. Also, I didn't say he played there for Fulham currently, I said has, past tense. He also frequently plays there for the national team. They don't always play that formation, and in the Bradley years he played out wide frequently.
I didn't want to argue about the formation Rodgers would use. I can't read his mind, and I doubt he's set it absolutely in stone after just a few weeks on the job. I know he's said on record that he wants to implement a philosophy, not a formation. Formations are based on the players you have.
In regards to your formation, if you want to talk about likelihood, he's pretty much said Aqua doesn't want to leave Italy. So including him (and spelling his name wrong) is a moot point. Secondly, Joe Cole has just as much a problem with pace as Dempsey does. Third, Suarez is not a center forward. He does not do well left isolated there up top by himself. We saw that this season. Carroll is the only CF, like him or not (though Sturridge could fill that role, since he prefers CF). 4th, Luis, Clint, and Gaston are highly ambidextrous. Luis has gone down the right flank plenty of times without cutting in this season. All left-footed players aren't as one dimensional as Downing. 5th, When did I say we shouldn't get a back up for Lucas? I just said were linked with these players, and I liked them. Quit putting words in my mouth.
But if not putting it in that formation has your knickers in a twist, fine.
-----reina---
glen---agger skrtle--jose
--------lucas-----------
---stevie--------Dempsey/Gaston
Luis---------------Gaston/Dempsey
-----------Carroll/Sturridge----------
I disagree with your analysis of Dempsey as a Gerrard type. He's not a box-to-box mid. However, he can score from distance. I think a hard-nosed trio of Dempsey, Gerrard, and Lucas would be effective. All three have a good passing game, can tackle, and both Gerrard and Clint are dangerous running in. Clint would also do well on the left (or right), with Gaston as a more creative influence deeper.