KopTalk.com Forums Football Liverpool FC Forum Did carra have a pop at benitez over xabi on ITV

dunk is ok for them to call me a liar mate ?

faz are you claiming that everything you said, say or will say in your life is the truth?.

once again i dont have no need to lie about things no need to impress anyone one with lies , i know what i know you choose to not believe it fine that up to you but if i say what i say it because from my knowledge its true .

well if people are entitled to not believe it, then i think that is exactly what happened, why are you complaining about it.

no disagree as much as you like but to call someone a liar sorry if that ok then something is wrong i havent called anyone a liar and wouldnt do that , debate it put a counter argument all fine but to just come out and accuse me of lying sorry wrong .

Faz, If you know you are right, then there is no need to worry about someone accusing you of lieing.

if someone is entitled to not believe you then i have news for you, they think you are lying, there is no getting away from that. you actually seem very upset that people dont believe you. why on earth do you give a fck? i couldnt give a fck if people think im lying, or call me a liar. "flames, youre a liar". grand, so what .

Just to interrupt

Does anyone know anything about Dahlias ? I have heard they grow in any kind of soil is that right?

So like, 4 pages of thread about whether Faz is a liar? Wtf? You either know him, or you don't. If you do, you would be able to back it up. If you don't then you're lying, mate. Given that all you've provided thus far is indignation, I'd have to lean towards the latter conclusion. Let me explain why.

Look, if you chat with Xabi, that's great. Maybe you don't like being called a liar, but you should expect people to question the authenticity of a claim such as you have made. Getting upset to the lengths you have on this thread about someone calling your bluff only makes it look like he's right and you've got nothing.

None of this changes the (Rafa) fact that Xabi chose to leave. Were he a true Red he would have stayed despite his relationship with the manager, just as Gerrard stayed despite the call(s) from Mourinho.

Aside: most managers are able to sell players who fight against them without any backlash because they are able to sign able replacements. Thanks to the owners at the time, Benitez did not really have that luxury, which is why so many people feel selling Alonso was a catastrophe. They (and by "they" I mean the "modern fan") would have crucified Paisley had Dalglish failed to fill Keegan's shoes, so it was a good thing Paisley had the money and the owners' support to buy by such a quality player. Instead we were largely forced to get an out-of-favour, injured guy from a club that owed us money, the same guy many people today believe could do a job for Liverpool were he ever allowed the opportunity by the owners. Regardless of all of this, Alonso only got himself on the transfer list because he was NOT the player he became in the wake of the Gareth Barry saga. I think even the die-hard anti-Benitez extremists should accept that had Alonso been all that, there was no reason for a cash-strapped manager to get involved with Barry whatsoever. A few goals from halfway isn't enough to cover for a guy who pulled his weight only when it suited him. For him to have suddenly stepped up to the heights he did simply showed that Benitez had been right that Alonso wasn't performing as he could. That Alonso then decided he would rather chase the payday at Madrid than accept that the manager was right, simply demonstrates for me that Alonso was not as much a Red as he claims. He's no better than Torres or Mascherano, frankly - except that he managed to blame Benitez and that stuck because so many Liverpool fans hate a successful manager.

And you can tell him that from me next time you send him an email.

more of a nettle fan