KopTalk.com Forums Football Liverpool FC Forum Would you Swap Newcastle's Squad for LFC's?

AGAIN HELL NO TO ALAN PARDREW, he is such a poor manager, mark my words if he hadn't of got that 4-4 draw to Arsenal when they imploded Newcastle would be middle table, it's only because of that belief and change in mentality that there playing so well, it's what we need more than better players or a better manager need confidence and change in mentality

Sorry to say this Desh - but this is absolute total nonsense....its like saying, Kenny is awsome - if we won all the games we lost we would be challenging for the premiership

No & No

Even if it was because of the 4-4 draw anything can allow a side to demotivate players and it did happen but, there is a level of resposibilty on maintaining the teams momentum.. If this is the case you can always say its because of the players for success. This can be seen in cases where good managers take over brilliant team but still lack the cutting edge to success..

No and no.

Pardew and Newcastle are having a good season but next will be the big test for them. There are always teams that over achieve. Look at Wigan a while ago and Hull. If they get to Europe it will be very difficult to keep this up next year. Their new players will no longer be un-knowns and will not have the same impact. Teams will know more about how to play them and ultimately snuff out their threat.

No.

exactly, its their day in the sun and fair play to them, had a great season and exceeded expectations, but they are just as likely to be relegated in three years time. if their better players continue this way they will be off to top 4 teams and itll be business as usual for tyneside.

Wilk what are you talking a about...The season so far shows that Newcastle are a better team than Liverpool (including their manager).
IF this and IF that! talk about FACTS not possibilities..
FACT next season Liverpool need to work harder to be as good as they were last season (what a sad statement as they were crap, this assumes the league finishes today)).
FACT Liverpool are no longer a dominant force

FACT - the last 20 years are sad times for liverpool - all we can hope is that FSG run Liverpool like a business - i.e. result driven - no sentiment, no history!

No to both, though Pardew's a decent manager. He'll probaby get sacked next season when they don't do quite as well.

but today pardew is oing better than kd