KopTalk.com Forums Football Liverpool FC Forum KD - Celtic's director of football 2001.

Interesting article from 2001 where kenny was celtic's director of football, laying all the blame for the poor signings at John Barnes's feet. What a gent! Can we presume then that Commolli's input is minimal and that Kenny is solely responsible for our poor players and tactics?

http://www.guardian.co.uk/football/2001/jan/23/newsstory.sport6

and after him O'Neil turned Celtic into the dominant power in the SL, and also made an impressive performance in Europe.

Is there a point to this?

Is there a point to you asking if 'there's a point to this?'

If you'd read the article you could see clearly what the point is.....the 2 or 3 supporters that kenny has left have been suggesting that kenny isn't to blame as comolli's makes the signings - the article above shows what kenny said previously under identical circumstances whilst passing the buck.

On a different note, I'm not sure if it's you or flames that have been closing so many threads lately but the majority that do get closed are the anti-dalglish ones. I feel confident that I am speaking for the majority of the forum when I ask for you to change your usual methods and carry out a bit of 'unbiased' moderating in future, please.

I think you might want to read what people post,maybe you have trouble understanding it,Commoli is not the manager so how he can be blamed for performances is beyond me,I dont see to many blaming him either but just saying things that suit your argument is your style.

I also see you have a problem with how the forum is run by myself and Flames,you can contact the admin or Dunk if your not happy.

Dunk @ koptalk.com

I suggest you learn how forums work first though,Multi threads on the same topic are pointless and interrupt the flow of the forum,hope that clears that up for you.

Carheex I know everyone values you and your opinion,

I certainly do.

The mods do what they do, I have seen things that surprise me and certain people seemed to get warned over and over again for the same thing whilst others get one chance and then banned.

But this is a great site and we are all lucky to be part of it

How do you know that Heggy, have you opened a poll?

I'm fully aware how most forums work, but this one is a bit different. There are people like you who close threads, not because a similar one exists but because it is going against your view point - and don't deny it. That shouldn't happen on this forum or any other forum with good moderators. Then there's the constant reminders not to abuse people, yet people like kop prophet do it routinely and get away with it whilst others get banned for far less. A little consistency is all that is required no matter what your opinions are. And for the record, I have informed dunk of this in the past but I think there have been more important things for him to focus on lately - which kind of means you're letting him AND the forum down. Pull your finger out.

Eh??? That IS my point! The article was for people who are saying don't blame kenny, blame commoli. You obviously haven't read it so I'll summarise:

Kenny says that although he was the director of football at celtic, john barnes is to blame for them being poor because he signed the players, trained them and told them how to play. What I am saying is that it is reasonable therefore thet kenny is solely responsible for our current predicament, despite the presence of Commoli, who some want to make the scapegoat. Man alive!!!!

Heggy why do you keep posting, subliminal threads and posts?

You'll be controversial and then put something like "But this is a great site and we are all lucky to be part of it" at the end. As if that you know you may get "done" for what you've said, but will add a little light at the end so it appears your angelic.

Listen, speak for yourself, if you value CarheeX opinion, then fine. But don't go branding everyone "values his opinion"

He's a loud an opinion, I don't have to agree with it or value it. As I'm sure CarheeX would say himself also.

If you haven't got anything good/clever/wise/or smart to say about Liverpool FC, then don't say it heggy. Everything is falling into the same category, of monotonous Liverpool and Kenny "bashing"....the forum is flooded with the same topic.

Is it so impossible to create a thoughtful thread or post that might spark valued debate....and new direction, for once?

Everything is the same old, same old.

You don't have to be positive 24/7, you can be negative 24/7 if you want!

But at least try and add something different mate.

Maybe even touch on, if Kenny and Commolli stay next season (what you don't want).....what has to be done, to get us back to our best next season and fighting at the top?