To be honest I did not think Carroll was MOTM, sure he got his goal but so did Suarez and so did Skrtel. Downing gets MOTM for me because he was everything we want him to be in that game.
Massively massively disagree. Downing got in good positions but his crossing all but twice was genuinely abysmal, like actually laughable. He wasted so many good opportunities to get a good ball in and we bought him for that purpose. That's why he quite rightly wasn't man of the match.
I thought Carroll was pretty good, henderson i agree with though, he is actually playing terribly at the moment.