KopTalk.com Forums Football Liverpool FC Forum Ratings v City

Reina 7 – A return to form after his mistakes in the league game. Solid and a safe pair of hands

Kelly 5 – Unfortunate that one moment of madness (that fortunately went unpunished) marred what otherwise was a satisfactory display

Skrtel 7 – Arguably our most improved player this season and was largely untroubled by City’s forwards

Agger 7 – Another solid display from the Dane

Johnson 7 – Got forward whether stationed on either flank and defended well throughout

Downing 5 – Another display that combined the good the bad and the indifferent. Played in patches which isn’t quite enough at this level – not to mention his pricetag

Henderson 6 – Poor decision making meant he was unable to benefit from his more enterprising and creative moments

Gerrard 7 – A welcome return from the captain capped by a perfectly taken penalty. Faded a little in the second half

Adam 6 – Did okay and made some important tackles but was sloppy at times and conceded quite a few fouls

Bellamy 5 – Was decent when he had the ball but unfortunately for Liverpool those moments were few and far between and most of the game seemed to bypass him

Carroll 4 – The team hardly played to his strengths but even if they had Andy looked unlikely to take advantage of it. Cumbersome movement, sloppy on the ball and didn't take advantage of his considerable bulk

Reina 7
Kelly 6
Skrtel 6
Agger 7
Johnson 6
Downing 5
Henderson 5
Gerrard 7
Adam 6
Bellamy 5
Carroll 5

reina 7

johnson 8

skrtel 7

agger 8

kelly 6

downing 5

Henderson 6

gerrard 8

Adam 6

Bellamy 7

Carroll 4

reina 7

johnson 8

skrtel 7

agger 7

kelly 5.5

downing 5

Henderson 6

gerrard 7.5

Adam 6

Bellamy 7

Carroll 4.5 ( one on one chance only real chance!) Hope he gets better service next time.
_________

Yes would pretty much agree Woolsey, except I would give Henderson a 6 and Johnson a 7 despite the rush of blood to the head resulting in a lunge that could have got him sent off, that said he had a great game imo, in a variety of positions. As Jim says Gerrard seemed to tire towards the end of the game, but boy didn't he take the penalty so well? hope all is ok with him.

apparently some c0ckbag was shining a green laser pen in his eyes while he was taking it.

i didnt see it in the game but i have seen it in the papers

Reina 9 –
Kelly 6 –
Skrtel 8 –
Agger 8 –
Johnson 8 –
Downing 5 –
Henderson 6
Gerrard 7 –
Adam 6 –
Bellamy 7
Carroll 35

Why do they allow those things to be sold some half wit near me was jailed for shining one at a police helicopter. The silly sod did it from his back garden. What purpose do the pens have other than causing mischief?

Straight lines for DIY maybe.