Hey Emp, we've heard your line about Xabi and Lucas far too much...you can't keep using these arguments in every topic! As for Carra, IMO his performance over the past 18 months (even when Xabi was here) have been average at best. He seems to put in one great performance every 8-10 weeks and everyone kisses his ring and says what a super he player he is. I admit that he was the corner stone of our defence in the past but it's time that others were now given the opportunity.