i dont think any fan would say no to a cup. they may say they rather have the CL position or PL title but if it was a choice of winning a cup and not winning anything, ALL fans would choice to win something regardless of how much value they put on that particular cup.
You would think that was the case with all supporters but it isn't.
I've had many arguments on other forums with fans of other clubs (Spurs mainly) who would rather finish 4th and get CL football than win a cup.
When you support a club that hasn't won trophies in donkeys years you would think a trophy in the cabinet is better than a 4th place position but unfortunately nowadays it's all about the money.
As for which match would I like to win i'd like to win both but due to the way we have dropped silly points in the league we need the league win more as it puts us joint on points with Chelsea and in order to get 4th or better we need to keep up amongst the top teams