KopTalk.com Forums Football Liverpool FC Forum FIFA 12 ratings?

Pepe Reina - 85
Doni - 76
Glen Johnson - 81
Jamie Carragher - 82
Sotirios Kyrgiakos - 77
Martin Skrtel - 81
Daniel Agger - 82
Fabio Aurelio - 77
John Flanagan - 75
Jack Robinson -73
Martin Kelly - 78
Lucas Leiva - 79/80
Steven Gerrard - 84
Raul Meireles - 82
Jordan Henderson - 78
Jay Spearing - 75
Jonjo Shelvey - 73
Charlie Adam - 79
Maxi Rodriguez - 79
Stewart Downing - 82
Joe Cole - 78/79
Dirk Kuyt - 82
Luis Suarez - 85
Andy Carroll - 81
David N'Gog - 77
Dani Pacheco - 75/76


Thoughts?

its about right to me

Some of them are a bit higher than I expected, in particular pacheco. I mean could anyone really say he is that close to being as good Kelly or Adam?

Pepe Reina - 86
Doni - 78
Glen Johnson - 83
Jamie Carragher - 84
Sotirios Kyrgiakos - 75
Martin Skrtel - 80
Daniel Agger - 83
Fabio Aurelio - 75
John Flanagan - 73
Jack Robinson -71
Martin Kelly - 80
Lucas Leiva - 81
Steven Gerrard - 86
Raul Meireles - 83
Jordan Henderson - 79
Jay Spearing - 72
Jonjo Shelvey - 70
Charlie Adam - 81
Maxi Rodriguez - 80
Stewart Downing - 82
Joe Cole - 80
Dirk Kuyt - 81
Luis Suarez - 86
Andy Carroll - 78
David N'Gog - 68
Dani Pacheco - 70

Couple of adjustments. 3:

Very, very interesting.

Out of curiosity, why do you believe N'gog will be rated lower than Pacheco?

I'll be switching back to PES myself next year.

Robinson and Shelvey most likely won't have ratings that high, i'd say. And i think Soto is a bit overrated there too. Aside from that, looks good!

Unfortunately the original post's ratings won't happen. Ratings like that would make us a 5 star team and we aren't that at the minute.

Been a PES man since 05 and I must say I got tempted to playing Fifa when a lot of mates brought it. Played the 09/01 version and I must say its one shet game. PES beats Fifa by miles, I don't care if you think its more realistic it just kills the excitement of the game. The systems they have for Master League mode on PES is just fantastic. I am eagerly awaiting PES12 to get a copy.

I think we forgot a key man

Name : Rating

, POULSON - 02