KopTalk.com Forums Football Liverpool FC Forum Raul of Alberto?

Looks like they are both history - which tells you just how bad Comoli is at assessing how good players atre and how m,uch they ought to cost

I'm certain it will end up here the same way it did at tottenham under him - I just hope we're not bottom the table like they were when he got the axe

Signing the likes of Henderson for £20m and letting Raul go for £13m is arguably one of the the worst transfer decisions in the history of the Premership

Get him out now before he takes outr club down the same route that Hicks and gillet tried to - ruin

First of all Jim Raul hasnt gone any where and how do we know Comoli has anything to do with what player ultimately come and go? Kenny doesnt stike me as the type of person to allow this to happen. Lets not speculate on things that havent happened and circumstances we know nothing about.

Up to now valuations of henderson in the media have been £15, £16, £16.5 and £20 million. We don't for sure how much Henderson cost, and we don't know how much Meireles will go for if he does go, the media haven't got a clue at all.

It strikes me that it's Comoli who hasn't got a clue and in answer to Murph's point, Comlio was brought into LFC because NFS adopted the failed continental model where a rechnical diurector or director of football gets the players in as opposed to the manager

and if kenny really is behind these moves - offloading the likes of merieless and Aqualani to get in people lkike henderson anbd adam then i am prepared to go as far as to say he's lost it - despite the brilliant work he did in cleaning up roy's mess

Jim are you by any chance a parrot?

Lol.. just for you, Jim...

i don't think kenny is that sort of person/manager either but he may have let his love for lfc rule his head on this matter, i can't see it and i really hope he does have complete control transfers

I wouldn't say it's a "failed" continental model. It works superbly in Italy to the extent that Serie A is won by an italian team every year. Similar successes have been made with Spanish teams in La Liga so why couldn't it work for us?

Thanks Bart that's one for the wall

TBH i always held Comoli is a bad light because of what he did at Tottenham (most of my footballing friends are Tottenham fans and I go and see them about 2-3 times each season) but I was willing to give him the benefit of the doubt when he joined - and at first, after the capture of Suarez I thoight he might be the mann for the job

I was even willing to overlook the £36m paid for Andy Caroll. He's certainly got bags of potential, is already an England international and whilst its easy to say in hindsight that we didn't neeed to sign him - at the time (Torres departure) we never could have known how quickly Suarez would have adapted to the English league and the partnership he build with the tireless kuyt

but decisions £20m for Henderson - whose performances really stood out for the U21s for all the wrong reasons - and news that he's willing to sacrifice the likes of Merieless, Rodriguez and Johnson - to get in players like Downing and Adam - strike me as a man who doesn't know what he's doing

'Bart'?! Lol, wtf!?

Do you know something we don't know? Because as far as i was aware, that was only random speculation from the tabloid rags, and not actually based on anything of importance. In fact, that's the very first i've heard of Johnson being 'sacrificed'. Don't believe all you hear. We've been linked with Mata, Aguero, Hazard etc. Are you equally convinced we're going to land all them?