KopTalk.com Forums Football Liverpool FC Forum no point in sacking Roy.

i know alot of you will disagree with me on this one but i really dont see how sacking Roy now would benefit us.i really dont think there is a manger out there who would come in and improve things.who-ever is the manager has the same shower of [oops] to pick from that roy has.our whole club is a shambles at the moment from top to bottom.our results are shocking and our performances are worse.
we talk about players not performing for him ect.these are feckin pro footballers and should remember they are not just playing for Roy Hodgson,they are playing for Liverpool fc and the fans that worship them.if they dont want to play to there potential then give us the money back and feck off.
they say a player cannot become a bad player over-night,the same can be said about managers.
Hodgson cant control and pass the ball for Kuyt the same as he cant defend for Glen Johnson thats their job, i just wish they were more capable of doing it.
all i'm saying is its about time the players stood up to be couted and gave the manager some support cos i dont feel the buck stops at Roys door.

Spurs>>>Ramos>>>2 points in November>>>>Sacked>>>Harry>>>instant improvement>>>

brown sacked,hull down.

Forgot about ramos - well pointed out - yeah, roy out, kenny in. Kenny more than anybody wants it so give iot to him - we'll be back to where we belong in a couple of years

while I agree that sacking him now or in the near future won't do anything in the short term I think in the long term we will benefit from a swift departure . I disagree that its the players fault even Johnson and personally I think he should not be in defence and if its written on theofficial site that he shouldnt be in defence then there must be a lot of people saying this. For me its 99 percent the fault of the manager. , while it is easy to blame the guy at the top. Its him who picks these players who are underperforming. And if he picks players in the wrong position (I mean a position they do not like or do not specialise in) then he must bear responsibility.

Jovanovich apparantly a striker personally I like this player, never had a chance, and if it is true what he said about lfc a strong manager wouldnt have him in the squad.
Cole, flair player played on the wing. Everyone knows hes not a winger. Miereles who I thought had a decent game and is an intelligent player has not been utilised in the centre of midfield more like a winger. Carragher who in my opinion should be retired did fairly well considering he was left back or someone was suggesting here he was on the wing today . Poulson well I think 80 percent of lfc supporters in england don't rate him atall . Babel ( who knows if he is good or not) but why did hodgson say 'show me you can do it' then not hardly give him a minute on the pitch. Even nasty old rafa wouldnt have done that.
Then konchesky for me he is better than nothing , but is considered by many as not being good enough. Also Agger for me a great centre back seems to have been given the cold shoulder.
Kuyt has never been that good on the ball.
The only part i would agree with isthat hodgson walked into a mess but he knew he was walking into a mess and he has done nothing to evolve the game of liverpool liverpool were not inept under benitez jsut disappointing. It is inept to produce no shots on goal and get out played by nationwide standard teams such as blackpool albeit they play a fluid attacking game. All of these bad decisions taken by roy and his employment of a style that might work at many clubs but not a club with a reputation for flowing football, and his refusal to change or adapt a system because he is too set in his ways means for me its 99 percent his fault . The manager must not destroy the confidence of the team OK if he cant develop we can't blame him but they look unhappier than they ever did last season ? Nothing to do with money everyone wants to win a match its human. Roy for me has to go.

We're not Hull.

We've watched most of these players play for years, we know what they're capable of, and it's better than what we're seeing now under Roy. It's Roy's job to get the best of the players - does anyone really think he's doing that? Or even that there's any sign of moving towards beginning to start doing that?

The kind of performances we're seeing suggest to me that psychologically our team is in a mess. Their confidence and belief is shot. We were seeing signs of that last season, and I had hoped that Roy's famed man-management skills would turn that around, but instead we're seeing the opposite. We're not going forwards, we're going backwards.

to be fair hull where down anyway and was too late in the season to be saved so that not a fair comment (I think he was sacked in late march, while ramos was sacked in November which gave harry time to repair)

I think he needs to go now as he clearly way out of his depth and kenny should come in and I don't think anyone can be as bad as Roy right now.

I dont get this...ask taibi,beckham, stam, veron etc how many cuddles they got from taggart.We can thank our glorious owners for this mess.They installed the manager,they have being making profits in the transfer windows and they are slowly killing this club. Liverpool >>> Corinthians.

does anyone else think that Roy lost the fans today

I know the kop will never sing for a manager to be sacked but with all the Kenny chants I think that is as good as.

O'neil