KopTalk.com Forums Football Liverpool FC Forum Who is the greatest English club side?

Good vid there Pickles, and two good pundits too, I enjoyed it, but it hasn't changed my view on the relevance of the competitive factor in each era. However I accept it's subjective and one can't be categorical about qualities issues in football, much of it's in the eye of the beholder, even the stats to a degree.

My take is this is about legacies, granted it is very subjective because personnel / players changes, from season to season to teams. The subject is the greatest ever English Club Side which I'd say was based on a season.

If it was greatest ever English Club, that would mean to me, the most highly decorated which currently is Liverpool FC.

The subject Carragher and Neville are conversing about is greatest ever legacy over a 3 year period of time.

They have taken a big part of subjectivity out by their points system which was defined before starting the exercise, so to me it's quite objective based on the set rules.

My opinion (which is the correct one)

Is the late seventies early eighties side managed by Paisley was the best ever, followed by the current side under klopp followed by the late eighties side managed by dalglish.

I think it's still early to put Klopp's team in the lot, it will need to win more trophies next season or at least a double this season

It's clear now that you were completely wrong