I thought he was beginning to shine under Klopp prior to his injury, even though I always thought he lacked end product. I'd give him time to get Somme sharpness back before I'd write him off. However having said that, he has been woeful since his return, and it's hard to think of who you'd take off for him, as the side has developed now under Klopp. I think he could well struggle to get his starting place back.
