Despite the terrible season we've just had Rodgers got us the closest we've been to winning the title for a couple of decades and also had us playing the best football we've seen for years.
Evidence before and since then seems to suggest that it was a fluke... or at least that his had less to do with Rodgers and more to do with Luis Suarez.
Why did Suarez not do it the season before then or with Kenny?
2010/11 - helped Liverpool go from twelfth in the league in mid-January to finish sixth.
2011/12 - write off due to stupid incident
2012/13 - shortlist for PFA Players' Player of the Year; second-top goalscorer in the Premier League Liverpool's player of the season.
He's been a class act since day one. The first two seasons he was leading up to his peak which it seems he reached last season. And he also had players like Coutino and Sturridge around him last season. Yes, BR takes credit for giving Suraez the freedom to play but it seems he stumble across the formula.