Cool not up there with Stanley Mathews or bobby Moore but yes good call what he has done in the modern game is fantastic but I would question the conduct off the field aspect if you read original criteria
thing is Stanley, how do we know what went on in Stanley Mathews private life or any of the older players, footballers off the field antics were never under the microscope back then so it's an unfair comparason. You mention Giggs private life being not so pure but you fail to mention Bobby Moore and the thieving case against him back in 1970 so you have to be fair. It has to be Ryan Giggs because greatness is measured in what you win and nobody in the History of the game has won what Giggs has, honours is what defines any sportsman...