KopTalk.com Forums Football Liverpool FC Forum The Perfect News Report!!!

He won't be going for anything less than 17 mill and neither should he. i'd keep him and I'd play him tomorrow

Carroll is a plan B type player. and we need that. if tiki taka cant work on some opponents then we need to throw the big man on and ruffle some feathers. make no mistake Carroll can change the game if he wants to and if played correctly. we cant play tika taka when he is on the pitch- it is that simple

for him to leave, 12 million aint enough.

i reeeeally can't wait till this window closes. too much going on. too many rumors. i mean, it's pretty much like this every time but with the new manager, i feel like it's a bit worse this time around because we really don't know much about him. he also seems to keep his mouth shut about stuff like this, which on one hand...i love and on the other, i hate it. it's honestly the carroll situation that i hate. i really do want him to stay for a few reasons. i am trying not to look at this with a bias, but i really don't see brendan taking 8mill less and i don't see it happening. it's also odd to me, because just the other day...carroll was due to start. he didn't. later that night, there was an article about it and brendan basically said he was "working well" and that he hoped that he would be fit for the man city game tomorrow. i don't know.

It is simple really.

If he plays in the Euro League he will be cup tied making him worth less than he already is.

i bet he will be on the bench today.

good point.makes perfect sense to me

The only way Carroll should be sold is if we can get a good replacement AND if we can get £20m for the man himself. Otherwise he should be kept on. I hope if he's still a Liverpool player come the end of the window, he can feel settled and get himself a few games and carry on where he left off last season formwise. He can still do a job for us.

Carroll does not suit our style either under Dalglish or Rodgers. Despite that the previous regime not only bought him but paid 4 times what he was worth. But we are where we are now and despite all this Carroll is still a useful player. Unless we get a reasonable offer he should stay.

And this is the problem - his original fee....it's not what he's worth so we shouldn't be baseing our valuation on anything to do with that figure. It cost people thier jobs so was obviously a huge mistake.
Put it another way, if he'd just spent 12 months at any other club with only a handful of half decent performances and scored just 4 league goals would you be saying he's worth a lot more than £12m??? Not a chance. If he'd been at Aston Villa last season and had exactly the same season, no one would pay more than £4m or £5m for him. People like you, think he's worth 4 times that figure just because we got ripped off ourselves.

I think he is worth £20m. He is an established England international. I do understand the point you are making Careex but based on performances, age, potential £20m is fair price.

Hahahahahaha