KopTalk.com Forums Football Liverpool FC Forum carrol to newcastle on loan- nufc make offer oh dear oh dear

Personally speaking Newcastle have no need for Carroll with Ba and Cisse up front.

I suspect they have agreed to sell either Ba or Cisse for big money and have asked for time to get a cheap replacement in ie Carroll.

Fortunately we have told Newcastle they will not mug us off and get Carroll on loan.

What irks me is that they sold him to us for 35million, if that is how much his value was when we bought him, if anything he has improved with Kennys coaching and is worth 25million minimum

i hope not, that's just a bad move. also, how would everyone feel about replacing carroll with ba? i honestly don't want carroll to go, but i really do think i would be willing if ba joined the squad. i read something about how he has something in his contract where soon if he gets an offer, they will let him leave. i could have read it wrong, i just skimmed through it a day or so ago.

One of Ba or Cisse are leaving but not us, or Newcastle would have attempted a swap deal and not a loan deal.

Personally I expect Ba or Cisse to join Man Utd before the end of the window

I doubt man u would go for Ba but I'd be surprised if no one starts sniffing round Cisse.

This has the fingerprints of Fergie all over it.
Sign Ciise from Newcastle for 20million then agree to keep mum until Newcastle can sign AC for peanuts from us.

I heard they're after some Brazalian called Lucas for £30 mil

i think it would be very odd if he went back to toon on loan. the toon fans would be a bit frosty i would say.

As shakespeare put it,
better to have bought donkey and sold it back to newcastle than to never have spent 35 million at all

One thing is sure newcastle have destabalized the liverpoool atack already, and they dont even need carrol