What a stupid argument going on here. Firstly, Rob Jones was an excellent right back. Was dogged with injuries throughout his career and had to retire very very early because of it.
Great player, yes, but this thread is called "favourite ever liverpool player", and even though Irish Kopite probably hasn't gone about it in the best manner, I think the point he was - validly - trying to make is why would someone pick him as their favourite player ever, and also what has his point got to do with the fact that he was a good player.
If people want to pick him as their favourite player, then yes, that's their prerogative, but by the same token, someone could pick Titi Camara.
