Now this season, we have no european football, we're still missing Gerrard, but we have Carroll and Suarez and we've invested heavily. Top 4 form last season with a weaker team, more injuries, and more games to play. Surely top 4 isn't too much to expect after the spending.
This is fair comment. But I do think that we had some "desperation factor" working for us in the latter half of the season, something akin to 'new manager syndrome' like what happened to Spurs. I think the loss to Wolves and the 10 000 empty seats at Anfield really woke everyone up. But I don't for a moment believe that squad could have maintained top 4 quality for an entire season (witness the two tame losses at the end), because we were already running on empty. I think it's important to remember though, Rafa, that Benitez could only get this squad to 7th prior to Hodgson; proof that it was shot full of holes in the aftermath of Alonsogate. We've only signed on 8 new people (including Jones) since then, which is far from a squad overhaul (though we have shed a lot of deadwood).
That's where my comment about it mostly being a club of average players comes from (prior to the summer, maybe still now). I think we all know the average quality of the players who left in the summer... We are definitely a better squad than last season, but perhaps we're still not top 4 quality - maybe only top 5 as we stand today. I feel that in general the new signings have all brought something to the club, and once they have an understanding of one another we can start to over-perform once more. But we're still some way off putting the puzzle together.
I do however feel that we should expect top 4. That is the promise that got us the investment, that is the goal that every staff member is working towards. If we're not going to expect them to deliver, then they can't succeed.