KopTalk


Quick Links: View All | Latest News | Liverpool FC Forum | Off Topic Forum | KopTalk Members | Help



Topic Options
Rate This Topic
#635343 - 20/09/20 01:46 PM Are Carra &Stevie G Liverpool legends?
Welsh_Wizard Offline
Under 23 Player

Registered: 07/05/12
Posts: 3621
When neither won the domestic league (our bread and butter) for us?

I would say no.

In modern times Liverpool legends include our title winning squad & European cup winning squad (any players who were in both) of a year before.


Discuss

Top

#635344 - 20/09/20 02:13 PM Re: Are Carra &Stevie G Liverpool legends? [Re: Welsh_Wizard]
elimmel Offline
Under 18 Player

Registered: 29/06/09
Posts: 787
By your logic, all the players from the good part of the last 30 years shouldn’t be considered as well.
And that includes the likes of Fowler, some of the treple and Istanbul CL winners. Duh....


Edited by elimmel (20/09/20 02:14 PM)

Top

#635345 - 20/09/20 02:37 PM Re: Are Carra &Stevie G Liverpool legends? [Re: elimmel]
Stanley Park Offline
Liverpool Legend

Registered: 21/10/09
Posts: 26964
Loc: Not the EU
of course they are
_________________________
IF YOU WANT TO BE HEARD SPEAK SOFTLY - BOB PAISLEY

Top

#635346 - 20/09/20 02:39 PM Re: Are Carra &Stevie G Liverpool legends? [Re: Welsh_Wizard]
Pickles Offline
Under 23 Player

Registered: 23/12/15
Posts: 4970
What a load of ball hang....Carra and Stevie G were unfortunate that we had Owners not willing to buy the PL or a Manager able to be backed.

Top

#635348 - 20/09/20 02:41 PM Re: Are Carra &Stevie G Liverpool legends? [Re: Welsh_Wizard]
ghostgoal Offline
Under 16 Player

Registered: 21/07/18
Posts: 193
Loc: Merseyside
absolutely ridiculous question. Gerrard is in the argument for best ever Liverpool Player in terms of natural talent and ability. He carried us on his back for some of the absolute worst times in the clubs history. He's a local lad born and raised scouser, who captained us for all of his career and lifted the CL in one of the most miraculous games ever played. He won every trophy there is to win with our club barring the league and was far and away our best player for the majority of those years. There is no question he is a legend. This agenda you have against him needs to stop. It's beyond farcical now.

Top

#635349 - 20/09/20 02:59 PM Re: Are Carra &Stevie G Liverpool legends? [Re: Welsh_Wizard]
EnergisedReds Offline
Liverpool Legend

Registered: 10/01/10
Posts: 21716
Originally Posted By Welsh_Wizard
When neither won the domestic league (our bread and butter) for us?

I would say no.

In modern times Liverpool legends include our title winning squad & European cup winning squad (any players who were in both) of a year before.


Discuss


Carra I am not sure but SG, definitely and by a few miles


Edited by EnergisedReds (20/09/20 02:59 PM)

Top

#635350 - 20/09/20 05:47 PM Re: Are Carra &Stevie G Liverpool legends? [Re: Welsh_Wizard]
Snakeye Online   happy
1st Team Regular

Registered: 30/12/09
Posts: 10696
Loc: New Zealand
They are legends for their longevity, trophies are important but they are not the only measuring stick. Gerrard is the greatest liverpool player I've seen and was there for 17 seasons. A lot of [oops] players have gotten a league medal should we consider those players legends? Chris smalling has won 2 league medals who as an average mid table player at best. Great players have never won trophies, messi no world cup, Ibrahimovic no cl they are still considered as one of the greats. Gerrard is the greatest player to never win the league which largely isnt his fault as he was carrying a poor liverpool team most of his career.

Caragher has the most appearances in club history, which speaks for itself, no player makes that amount of appearances without merit.
_________________________
Back to Back World Champions baby!

Top


Moderator:  KopTalk Team 
Shout Box


Advertisements

Liverpool FC Discussion
Number of games this season
by RedJohn
25/10/20 10:05 AM
Liverpool v Sheffield United
by elimmel
25/10/20 06:27 AM
Dayot Upamecano vs Matip, Gomes & VVD
by TheMightyLFC
24/10/20 01:31 PM
Carlo Ancelotti comments on Pickford-VVD incident
by EnergisedReds
22/10/20 03:17 PM
Ajax v Liverpool
by ecnirp98
22/10/20 12:35 PM

General Discussion
Batman takes over the Liver Building!
by Pickles
16/10/20 11:32 AM
Trump v Biden
by Pickles
13/10/20 09:58 AM
Music thread! (now epic)
by lumba
07/10/20 06:37 PM
SHOCK REPORT: This Week CDC Quietly Updated COVID-19
by EnergisedReds
02/10/20 10:21 AM
Growlers things that make you happy thread!
by lumba
26/09/20 06:55 PM

Top Posters (30 Days)
Pickles 99
ecnirp98 82
Stanley Park 45
EnergisedReds 41
Snakeye 40
Welsh_Wizard 39
lumba 23
EMP 18
elimmel 16
The Kop Prophet 15