KopTalk


Quick Links: View All | Latest News | Liverpool FC Forum | Off Topic Forum | KopTalk Members | Help



Page 1 of 2 1 2 >
Topic Options
Rate This Topic
#630831 - 20/01/20 03:58 PM Is Henderson a better captain than Gerrard?
Welsh_Wizard Offline
Under 23 Player

Registered: 07/05/12
Posts: 3538
That is the question.

As captain Hendo will have lifted

The CL
EURO SUPER CUP
WORLD CLUB CUP
PREMIER LEAGUE


Gerrard failed to lead us to the Prem.

so in terms of trophies and leading us to Victory does Hendo surpass Gerrard?

Top

#630832 - 20/01/20 05:32 PM Re: Is Henderson a better captain than Gerrard? [Re: Welsh_Wizard]
EnergisedReds Offline
Liverpool Legend

Registered: 10/01/10
Posts: 20850
Originally Posted By Welsh_Wizard
That is the question.

As captain Hendo will have lifted

The CL
EURO SUPER CUP
WORLD CLUB CUP
PREMIER LEAGUE


Gerrard failed to lead us to the Prem.

so in terms of trophies and leading us to Victory does Hendo surpass Gerrard?


Stop talking crap, will you? No true LFC fan gives a shyte

Top

#630833 - 20/01/20 06:09 PM Re: Is Henderson a better captain than Gerrard? [Re: Welsh_Wizard]
The Kop Prophet Offline
Under 16 Player

Registered: 21/05/18
Posts: 306
Another pointless thread. For years, Gerrard strapped this team on his back and won games single handedly. We never invested in more than one world class player at a time to complement him. It's sad that he had to play through the Hicks and Gillet days - as well as a string of poor managers. Hendo is fantastic but a completely different type of player - and with a far better supporting cast.

Top

#630835 - 20/01/20 06:12 PM Re: Is Henderson a better captain than Gerrard? [Re: Welsh_Wizard]
Oli Offline
Under 16 Player

Registered: 14/09/16
Posts: 278
Loc: Iceland
Yes we woudln´t have won anything if Hendo was at that time playing instead of Gerrard. How would Hendo have scored that goal in the cup final against West Ham just to name one goal.

Top

#630838 - 20/01/20 07:21 PM Re: Is Henderson a better captain than Gerrard? [Re: The Kop Prophet]
Welsh_Wizard Offline
Under 23 Player

Registered: 07/05/12
Posts: 3538
Originally Posted By The Kop Prophet
Another pointless thread. For years, Gerrard strapped this team on his back and won games single handedly. We never invested in more than one world class player at a time to complement him. It's sad that he had to play through the Hicks and Gillet days - as well as a string of poor managers. Hendo is fantastic but a completely different type of player - and with a far better supporting cast.



That is a load of rubbish.
Gerrard was supported with plenty of world class players.

Alonso, Mascherano are far better than any of our current midfielders. Torres would easily get in our front 3, Carra - vast improvement on any of VVD partners.

Reina in his prime just as good as Allison.

That's without mentioning he played with Suarez, Sterling and Sturridge.

what are you smoking?

Top

#630839 - 20/01/20 08:10 PM Re: Is Henderson a better captain than Gerrard? [Re: Welsh_Wizard]
wilkij1975 Online   content
Liverpool Legend

Registered: 26/06/09
Posts: 21979
Loc: Northamptonshire
Originally Posted By Welsh_Wizard
That is the question.

As captain Hendo will have lifted

The CL
EURO SUPER CUP
WORLD CLUB CUP
PREMIER LEAGUE


Gerrard failed to lead us to the Prem.

so in terms of trophies and leading us to Victory does Hendo surpass Gerrard?


No. Hendo has a much better team around him than Gerrard ever did.

Top

#630842 - 20/01/20 09:30 PM Re: Is Henderson a better captain than Gerrard? [Re: wilkij1975]
ecnirp98 Offline
1st Team Squad

Registered: 03/03/16
Posts: 5010
Loc: Madchester
Originally Posted By wilkij1975
Originally Posted By Welsh_Wizard
That is the question.

As captain Hendo will have lifted

The CL
EURO SUPER CUP
WORLD CLUB CUP
PREMIER LEAGUE


Gerrard failed to lead us to the Prem.

so in terms of trophies and leading us to Victory does Hendo surpass Gerrard?


No. Hendo has a much better team around him than Gerrard ever did.


Agree, We often had 2 or 3 top quality (World Class) players, but then there was a massive drop off to the rest of the team.

Gerrard would be a star in the current team, supplying passes to the front 3 and breaking from MF scoring goals, Henderson would not raise the teams Gerrard was in, he's a very good player, but he's a good team player, he cannot really raise a team a level n his own or score a winner from 30 yards, and that's not knocking Henderson, he's an excellent player.

I think Henderson is a better captain though, he seems to have a better connection with his team mates, he trusts them and they have bonded as a team, most of Gerrard's team mates looked up to him as a hero and just used to give him the ball as soon as they could, so the pressure would be on Gerrard to do something special and win the game on his own, which made us a weaker team overall.


Top

#630864 - 21/01/20 01:05 PM Re: Is Henderson a better captain than Gerrard? [Re: ecnirp98]
Stanley Park Offline
Liverpool Legend

Registered: 21/10/09
Posts: 26482
Loc: Not the EU
Henderson the better captain of the two for me. Gerrard obviously the better player. But man management Henderson has the X factor
_________________________
IF YOU WANT TO BE HEARD SPEAK SOFTLY - BOB PAISLEY

Top

#630865 - 21/01/20 01:08 PM Re: Is Henderson a better captain than Gerrard? [Re: Welsh_Wizard]
redordead13 Offline
1st Team Squad

Registered: 03/08/11
Posts: 8563
Loc: Atlanta, Georgia
We are lucky to have been captained by both.

Top

#630869 - 21/01/20 01:19 PM Re: Is Henderson a better captain than Gerrard? [Re: Oli]
RedJohn Offline
Under 23 Player

Registered: 28/11/11
Posts: 1442
Originally Posted By Oli
Yes we woudln´t have won anything if Hendo was at that time playing instead of Gerrard. How would Hendo have scored that goal in the cup final against West Ham just to name one goal.


What does a 'better' captain entail?

Henderson's immense at the moment, but I bet SG watches on with envy at playing with these players, under Klopp.
Hendo's become a great captain and will win more than Stevie ever did, but he'll never be the same player. Not that either will mind.

Top

Page 1 of 2 1 2 >

Moderator:  KopTalk Team 
Shout Box


Advertisements

Liverpool FC Discussion
PFA player of the year
by Snakeye
18/02/20 04:26 AM
Man City banned from Champions League for 2 seasons
by ecnirp98
17/02/20 11:56 PM
What is the correct punishment for Man City?
by ecnirp98
17/02/20 07:34 PM
City threat to blow the lid on rivals financial activities!
by Pickles
17/02/20 03:54 PM
It's Never Over Until It's Over
by TheMightyLFC
17/02/20 12:57 PM

General Discussion
This is Brilliant...
by Pickles
16/02/20 12:56 PM
Coronavirus - Harvard epidemiolgist "Virus is thermonuclear"
by Pickles
14/02/20 05:03 PM
Prince of Wales comes to Liverpool
by Stanley Park
06/02/20 10:18 PM
My god it's happened !
by EnergisedReds
06/02/20 06:07 AM
@11 PM - 31 January 2020
by EnergisedReds
03/02/20 05:08 PM

Top Posters (30 Days)
Pickles 106
EnergisedReds 100
ecnirp98 78
AccaBoosty 58
wilkij1975 45
Snakeye 34
van Gogh 34
redordead13 33
Stanley Park 29
TheMightyLFC 28