KopTalk


Quick Links: View All | Latest News | Liverpool FC Forum | Off Topic Forum | KopTalk Members | Help



Page 3 of 3 < 1 2 3
Topic Options
Rate This Topic
#628583 - 25/10/19 02:31 PM Re: VAR in the EPL [Re: The Kop Prophet]
redordead13 Offline
1st Team Squad

Registered: 03/08/11
Posts: 8437
Loc: Atlanta, Georgia
Originally Posted By The Kop Prophet
It's really quite simple. Just correct every wrong call - that's it! No need to worry about embarrassing the ref - no other sport does. So far, we use VAR to get every single handball right, every single fractional offside right.... but it's been absolutely useless at overturning the ref's wrong decisions on pens and goals. So what's the point? If incorrect decisions are allowed to stand - or the refs can't be bothered to check the monitors - or we can't overturn anything a ref has called that leads to a pen or a goal then there's no point having it at all.

VAR is fine - the way we use it is moronic.


100% correct. I have no idea why in this country the ref's ego or standing has to be a factor. Refs should not be famous. They should do their job and call the games. That's it.

Whether the ref is being "undermined" is not a factor. The rules exist for a fair game, and the rules should be enforced fairly and correctly. I watch a lot of Serie A, MLS, and the Bundesliga, and VAR works fine there. The English FA, as usual, is being a bunch of dinosaurs, afraid of stepping on their ref chummies' toes. It's ludicrous.

Top

#628993 - 07/11/19 07:05 AM Re: VAR in the EPL [Re: redordead13]
EnergisedReds Online   content
Liverpool Legend

Registered: 10/01/10
Posts: 20610
Originally Posted By redordead13
Originally Posted By The Kop Prophet
It's really quite simple. Just correct every wrong call - that's it! No need to worry about embarrassing the ref - no other sport does. So far, we use VAR to get every single handball right, every single fractional offside right.... but it's been absolutely useless at overturning the ref's wrong decisions on pens and goals. So what's the point? If incorrect decisions are allowed to stand - or the refs can't be bothered to check the monitors - or we can't overturn anything a ref has called that leads to a pen or a goal then there's no point having it at all.

VAR is fine - the way we use it is moronic.


100% correct. I have no idea why in this country the ref's ego or standing has to be a factor. Refs should not be famous. They should do their job and call the games. That's it.

Whether the ref is being "undermined" is not a factor. The rules exist for a fair game, and the rules should be enforced fairly and correctly. I watch a lot of Serie A, MLS, and the Bundesliga, and VAR works fine there. The English FA, as usual, is being a bunch of dinosaurs, afraid of stepping on their ref chummies' toes. It's ludicrous.


Watching the City game against Atlanta and the use of VAR is much much better and the ref takes complete responsibility by going to check himself the penalty decision. The EPL refs should learn

Top

#629008 - 07/11/19 02:59 PM Re: VAR in the EPL [Re: AccaBoosty]
Hercules/AF 58 Offline
1st Team Squad

Registered: 11/03/11
Posts: 8475
Originally Posted By AccaBoosty
Originally Posted By Hercules/AF 58
Originally Posted By elimmel
Yes and the monitors are there. But not one ref went to view it and weíre heading into match week 10

Why should the ref's employ a dog and then bark themselves? Surely they can rely on those already employed reading and scrutinising the monitors?
VAR slows things up enough as it is, without the ref's trundling off to view a monitor when he has the relevant information already in his ear.


Yes I understand what you are saying but when VAR is new and we look at the experience of the referee Atkinson against that of the VAR official we are talking about 15 years in PL v 15 games in the PL. Given that level of experience difference we are not going to get much reversed unless the man in the middle can own up to his error.

Yes I can see the point there. What I don't understand is how Atkinson got to be in charge of the Var, given his well known decisions where Liverpool is concerned?

Top

#629015 - 07/11/19 03:37 PM Re: VAR in the EPL [Re: EnergisedReds]
redordead13 Offline
1st Team Squad

Registered: 03/08/11
Posts: 8437
Loc: Atlanta, Georgia
Originally Posted By EnergisedReds
Originally Posted By redordead13
Originally Posted By The Kop Prophet
It's really quite simple. Just correct every wrong call - that's it! No need to worry about embarrassing the ref - no other sport does. So far, we use VAR to get every single handball right, every single fractional offside right.... but it's been absolutely useless at overturning the ref's wrong decisions on pens and goals. So what's the point? If incorrect decisions are allowed to stand - or the refs can't be bothered to check the monitors - or we can't overturn anything a ref has called that leads to a pen or a goal then there's no point having it at all.

VAR is fine - the way we use it is moronic.


100% correct. I have no idea why in this country the ref's ego or standing has to be a factor. Refs should not be famous. They should do their job and call the games. That's it.

Whether the ref is being "undermined" is not a factor. The rules exist for a fair game, and the rules should be enforced fairly and correctly. I watch a lot of Serie A, MLS, and the Bundesliga, and VAR works fine there. The English FA, as usual, is being a bunch of dinosaurs, afraid of stepping on their ref chummies' toes. It's ludicrous.


Watching the City game against Atlanta and the use of VAR is much much better and the ref takes complete responsibility by going to check himself the penalty decision. The EPL refs should learn


MLS teams are in the UCL now? wink

Top

#629019 - 07/11/19 05:39 PM Re: VAR in the EPL [Re: redordead13]
EnergisedReds Online   content
Liverpool Legend

Registered: 10/01/10
Posts: 20610
Originally Posted By redordead13
Originally Posted By EnergisedReds
Originally Posted By redordead13
Originally Posted By The Kop Prophet
It's really quite simple. Just correct every wrong call - that's it! No need to worry about embarrassing the ref - no other sport does. So far, we use VAR to get every single handball right, every single fractional offside right.... but it's been absolutely useless at overturning the ref's wrong decisions on pens and goals. So what's the point? If incorrect decisions are allowed to stand - or the refs can't be bothered to check the monitors - or we can't overturn anything a ref has called that leads to a pen or a goal then there's no point having it at all.

VAR is fine - the way we use it is moronic.


100% correct. I have no idea why in this country the ref's ego or standing has to be a factor. Refs should not be famous. They should do their job and call the games. That's it.

Whether the ref is being "undermined" is not a factor. The rules exist for a fair game, and the rules should be enforced fairly and correctly. I watch a lot of Serie A, MLS, and the Bundesliga, and VAR works fine there. The English FA, as usual, is being a bunch of dinosaurs, afraid of stepping on their ref chummies' toes. It's ludicrous.


Watching the City game against Atlanta and the use of VAR is much much better and the ref takes complete responsibility by going to check himself the penalty decision. The EPL refs should learn


MLS teams are in the UCL now? wink


Ok Atalanta

Top

Page 3 of 3 < 1 2 3

Moderator:  KopTalk Team 
Shout Box


Advertisements

Liverpool FC Discussion
Leicester now Liverpool's biggest PL threat?
by EnergisedReds
18/11/19 02:24 AM
Disrespectful comments from BBC & Southgate about Gomez?
by EnergisedReds
17/11/19 04:31 PM
City lose appeal against Financial Fair Play investigations
by van Gogh
17/11/19 09:57 AM
Alexander Arnold future midfielder ?
by AccaBoosty
17/11/19 12:23 AM
One Game Ban & £50,000 fine for Silva
by EnergisedReds
16/11/19 07:25 PM

General Discussion
The real origins of Brexit by Russell Taylor
by wilkij1975
18/11/19 07:34 AM
pedo prince
by EMP
17/11/19 09:28 PM
Growlers things that make you happy thread!
by lumba
12/11/19 07:22 PM
Who would you vote for in the next UK General Election?
by EnergisedReds
07/11/19 03:24 PM
Music thread! (now epic)
by lumba
01/11/19 08:47 PM

Top Posters (30 Days)
EnergisedReds 176
wilkij1975 127
EMP 105
Stanley Park 72
ecnirp98 52
Pickles 47
Markhutch1 42
van Gogh 36
Dunk 35
redordead13 30