KopTalk

Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
Rate Thread
Page 1 of 3 1 2 3
#564779 21/05/17 11:17 PM
Joined: Sep 2012
Posts: 1,039
W
Under 23 Player
OP Offline
Under 23 Player
W
Joined: Sep 2012
Posts: 1,039
Mignolet - 8 Best season for us so far. Earned another season as no 1.
Clyne - 6 Ok defensively, doesn't really know what to do going forwards. Could lose place.
Matip - 7 What a free. Our best defender just needs to play more often.
Lovren - 6 Improvement but still a lot of mistakes and very erratic.
Milner - 6 much better than Moreno defensively but slows the game down cutting in.
Can - 7 Rubbish at the start but looked quality in DM second half of season
Wijnaldum - 7 Quiet most of the time but had an impact when it mattered. Good, not great.
Lallana - 7 Started well, faded after injury. Not great second half of season.
Mane - 8 Briliant, just a shame he missed so many games
Firmino - 7 Worked hard and scored some important goals but doesn't have the quality to lead the line. Anonymous in alot of games and wasteful at times.
Coutinho - 8 Started the season looking word class and finished it looking world class. Shame about the injury in the middle.

Others:
Karius 4 - Disaster
Klavan 5 - Had some good games and some disasters. Backup only.
Lucas 6 - Credible, Ok when in midfield and did his best at CB but should never have played there and cost us points when he did.
Henderson - 6 Was having a decent season but missed too many games.
Sturridge 4 - Barely played and only impacted 1-2 games when he did.
Origi 6 - Works hard but lacking quality.

Others not done enough to get a rating.

Joined: Jan 2011
Posts: 2,088
C
Under 23 Player
Offline
Under 23 Player
C
Joined: Jan 2011
Posts: 2,088
An astute appraisal Welshie. But credit must be given to Jurgen Klopp also because I doubt if the players would have performed as well without his leadership.
Interestingly I saw a panel discussion on ESPN with Steve Nicol who reckons we need 5 or 6 new signings who are "game changers" and I would agree with him also.

Joined: Aug 2010
Posts: 9,605
V
1st Team Squad
Offline
1st Team Squad
V
Joined: Aug 2010
Posts: 9,605
Originally Posted By welshred11
Mignolet - 8 Best season for us so far. Earned another season as no 1.
Clyne - 6 Ok defensively, doesn't really know what to do going forwards. Could lose place.
Matip - 7 What a free. Our best defender just needs to play more often.
Lovren - 6 Improvement but still a lot of mistakes and very erratic.
Milner - 6 much better than Moreno defensively but slows the game down cutting in.
Can - 7 Rubbish at the start but looked quality in DM second half of season
Wijnaldum - 7 Quiet most of the time but had an impact when it mattered. Good, not great.
Lallana - 7 Started well, faded after injury. Not great second half of season.
Mane - 8 Briliant, just a shame he missed so many games
Firmino - 7 Worked hard and scored some important goals but doesn't have the quality to lead the line. Anonymous in alot of games and wasteful at times.
Coutinho - 8 Started the season looking word class and finished it looking world class. Shame about the injury in the middle.

Others:
Karius 4 - Disaster
Klavan 5 - Had some good games and some disasters. Backup only.
Lucas 6 - Credible, Ok when in midfield and did his best at CB but should never have played there and cost us points when he did.
Henderson - 6 Was having a decent season but missed too many games.
Sturridge 4 - Barely played and only impacted 1-2 games when he did.
Origi 6 - Works hard but lacking quality.

Others not done enough to get a rating.





Sounds about right to me aswell.

But just a question: Did he take an English word class at the beginning of the season? Didn't know that! grin

Joined: May 2012
Posts: 3,661
W
Under 23 Player
Offline
Under 23 Player
W
Joined: May 2012
Posts: 3,661
I would probably agree with all of those ratings.
It makes Jürgen's job so much harder in the summer when you realize our squad is thin as a thread.

I wouldn't have given any player 8, they all suffer from inconsistent performance's game to game.

Joined: May 2012
Posts: 1,946
P
Under 23 Player
Offline
Under 23 Player
P
Joined: May 2012
Posts: 1,946
agree with those

Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 4,077
M
Under 23 Player
Offline
Under 23 Player
M
Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 4,077
Can't agree with mignolet getting an 8. 7 at best.

He was dropped at the start of the season and he was poor for most of it, still made some mistakes but also some match winning saves.

Origi is still young and yet to play as our main striker. Often thrown out on the wing, we used to praise kuyt for his work rate without any goals or assists. Origi works very hard too. 6 is harsh.

Wijnaldum has been one of our best players after mane and coutinho. He's a future captain for me and he'll be massive for us next year.

Good ratings tho

Joined: Dec 2009
Posts: 10,988
1st Team Regular
Offline
1st Team Regular
Joined: Dec 2009
Posts: 10,988
Mignolet 6 are we forgetting his mistakes? , Lovren 3 struggled all season, Klopp 8. Rest looks good.


Back to Back World Champions baby!
Joined: Jan 2010
Posts: 22,926
Liverpool Legend
Offline
Liverpool Legend
Joined: Jan 2010
Posts: 22,926
Originally Posted By Snakeye
Mignolet 6 are we forgetting his mistakes? , Lovren 3 struggled all season, Klopp 8. Rest looks good.


Mignolet didn't do too many mistakes after getting back the number 1 position, so 6 is too low IMO, 7 is about right. 3 is well below average, I would say Lovren was just above so 6 for me.

Joined: Jan 2010
Posts: 22,926
Liverpool Legend
Offline
Liverpool Legend
Joined: Jan 2010
Posts: 22,926
Originally Posted By Mr Bojangles
Can't agree with mignolet getting an 8. 7 at best.

He was dropped at the start of the season and he was poor for most of it, still made some mistakes but also some match winning saves.

Origi is still young and yet to play as our main striker. Often thrown out on the wing, we used to praise kuyt for his work rate without any goals or assists. Origi works very hard too. 6 is harsh.

Wijnaldum has been one of our best players after mane and coutinho. He's a future captain for me and he'll be massive for us next year.

Good ratings tho


Origi doesn't deserve more than 6, he played more as a central striker at least since Mane got injured. Is he any much younger than Kane? I would get rid quickly, for me even Caroll is a better striker.

Joined: Aug 2011
Posts: 8,564
1st Team Squad
Offline
1st Team Squad
Joined: Aug 2011
Posts: 8,564
Originally Posted By RedsforChampions
Originally Posted By Mr Bojangles
Can't agree with mignolet getting an 8. 7 at best.

He was dropped at the start of the season and he was poor for most of it, still made some mistakes but also some match winning saves.

Origi is still young and yet to play as our main striker. Often thrown out on the wing, we used to praise kuyt for his work rate without any goals or assists. Origi works very hard too. 6 is harsh.

Wijnaldum has been one of our best players after mane and coutinho. He's a future captain for me and he'll be massive for us next year.

Good ratings tho


Origi doesn't deserve more than 6, he played more as a central striker at least since Mane got injured. Is he any much younger than Kane? I would get rid quickly, for me even Caroll is a better striker.


About three years younger. . .

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3

Moderated by  KopTalk Team 

Link Copied to Clipboard
ShoutChat
Comment Guidelines: Do post respectful and insightful comments. Don't flame, hate, spam.
Advertisements
Liverpool FC Discussion